Toaster That Cooks Eggs: Yes You Can Cook Eggs in a Toaster Oven

Remember when toasters just cooked bread?

Those were bleak, primitive times when whipping up a batch of eggs for breakfast meant deploying half a dozen pieces of cookware and slaving away over a grease-spattered stovetop.

But that era is mercifully past. Nowadays, there are toasters that can perform all sorts of amazing functions along with their primary bread browning application, including poaching eggs to a perfect toothsome consistency.

A toaster that cooks eggs? Whoever heard of such a thing?

You have, now. And now that you have, consider adding one of these miraculously convenient egg-cooking toasters to your growing collection of futuristic culinary doodads.

Top Four Toaster With Egg Maker Choices

There are scads of toaster egg makers out there. For your shopping pleasure, we’ve narrowed down the myriad options to four standout picks. Each of them earns high marks across several key categories, including overall performance, efficiency, ease-of-use, design, and affordability.

Top Four Toaster With Egg Maker Choices:

• West Bend 78500 2-Slice Breakfast Station With Egg Cooker
• Nostalgia CLBS3AQ Classic Retro 3-in-1 Breakfast Station
• Back to Basics TEM500PDWH Paula Deen Egg and Muffin Toaster
• Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

1. West Bend 78500 2-Slice Breakfast Station With Egg Cooker

This West Bend toaster egg cooker has become a favorite of online shoppers thanks to its ability to produce a complete, balanced breakfast in the blink of an eye.

Half of this sleek, simplistic is a two-slot toaster with wide slots for easy insertion and extraction. The other half is a convertible mini-cooker, which you can use to poach or scramble a pair of eggs while your carbs are browning.

What’s more, the 78500 comes with an additional slotted egg tray that allows users to soft- or hard-boil up to eight eggs at a time. If you’re an egg lover, it doesn’t get much better than this.

Pros

• Spacious two-slot toaster
• Variable temperature and toast settings
• Egg cooker reaches temperatures of up to 212℉ (100℃)
• Includes meat tray for warming precooked breakfast meats
• Extremely economical

Cons

• Temperamental heating elements
• Prone to defects

2. Nostalgia CLBS3AQ Classic Retro 3-in-1 Breakfast Station

Another classic case of “anything you can do, I can do better,” the 3-in-1 Breakfast Station from Nostalgia one-ups the West Bend by working in a miniature non-stick griddle that enables users to fry as well as poach, scramble, and boil.

One major perk of this model is that it can actually cook bacon, sausage, and other meats rather than just warming them over. This feature alone is bound to appeal to breakfast buffs who are looking for an all-in-one way to rustle up a fresh-cooked meal with all the fixins.

The surprisingly capable griddle can also be used to pull off more complicated dishes like omelets, frittatas, and hashbrowns, making this turbo-charged toaster the most versatile on the list.

Pros

• Two-slot toaster with wide slots
• Mini-griddle can be used to fry, scramble, or poach
• Six-slot removable egg tray for soft- and hard-boiling
• Includes silicone ring for neater, more presentable eggs
• Cooks breakfast meats from start to finish

Cons

• Takes up quite a bit of space

3. Back to Basics TEM500PDWH Paula Deen Egg and Muffin Toaster

Just like its namesake celebrity chef and beloved TV personality, Back to Basics’ Paula Deen-branded Egg and Muffin Toaster is unostentatious and full of folksy charm.

This no-nonsense machine is built to handle two slices of bread or a sliced bagel, muffin, or croissant, plus poach an egg while it’s at it. These concurrent cooking options make it possible to prepare everything you need to throw together a basic breakfast sandwich in less than five minutes.

Such time-saving simplicity promises to be no small benefit if you frequently find yourself rushing out the door in the morning.

Pros

• Extra-wide slots to accommodate items like bagels and English muffins
• Great for making 2- or 3-ingredient breakfast sandwiches
• Boils up to 4 eggs at a time
• Auto shut-off safety feature

Cons

• Limited capacity and functionality compared to similar models
• Can be hard to track down

4. Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Technically, our final highlighted product is a sandwich maker, not a toaster. Seeing as how it both toasts bread and cooks eggs, we feel justified in saying, “close enough.”

Hamilton Beach that when it comes to AM food prep, efficiency is priority number one. To this end, their Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker heats and assembles not one but two sandwiches side-by-side in under five minutes. They’ve managed to streamline the process by coming up with a design that carries out the toasting and egg-cooking tasks simultaneously.

If you love wolfing down hot, melty breakfast sandwiches on the go but hate putting them together yourself, this is the gadget for you.

Pros

• Effortless four-step sandwich making procedure
• Holds up to two eggs and four pieces of bread at once
• Cooking compartments can be used separately if desired
• Easy to use, clean, and reset

Cons

• Offers very little in the way of control or adjustability
• Circular griddle trays will only work with English muffins or bagels

Can You Cook Eggs in a Toaster Oven?

In a normal toaster oven? Only in your wildest dreams. But in a decked-out, multi-functional toaster oven with enough add-ons to make a Swiss Army knife jealous? You better believe it.

As it happens, conventional toasters aren’t the only appliances pulling double duty on busy mornings. Toaster ovens (like our personal favorite, the Elite Gourmet Countertop Toaster Oven from Maxi-Matic) have also begun catching on as readymade egg-cooking solutions with thrifty cooks with more good sense than spare time.

These hybrid appliances feature separate griddle trays that hijack the radiant heat from the internal oven to cook eggs alongside other first-meal fare like toast, bagels, croissants, and pastries. Just crack your eggs directly onto the top tray, cover them up, and pull them off whenever your bread is done toasting.

If you’re the kind of person who finds ordinary pop-up toasters anxiety-inducing, a toaster oven with an integrated cooking tray can be every bit as useful for cranking out firm yet fluffy eggs in a jiffy with no extraneous cookware required.

How Do You Cook Eggs in a Toaster Oven?

You may be surprised that you may be able to use your current toaster oven without any special attachments.

Conclusion

Sure, you could keep cooking your eggs the old-fashioned way—preheating the pan, dirtying up countless dishes and utensils, and watching the clock count down the minutes until you’re late for work while you babysit your breakfast. Or you could simplify your morning routine by equipping yourself with a toaster that does everything you need it to do with the press of a button.

For our money, a toaster that cooks eggs is a great use of your money and an egg-cellent way to start off the day.